A rebellion is brewing within the Republican Party as members of the Freedom Caucus consider a move to oust Speaker of the House Mike Johnson. The dissatisfaction with Johnson’s leadership highlights deeper divisions within the GOP and threatens to reignite chaos in House leadership when Congress reconvenes in January.
Tensions have been simmering among Freedom Caucus members, who accuse Johnson of being an ineffective leader incapable of advancing the party’s legislative goals. According to a report from Raw Story, several Republicans are weighing whether to withhold support for Johnson, potentially leading to another battle for the speakership.
Eric Thompson Show
“The speaker’s got work to do,” an anonymous member of the Freedom Caucus remarked. “There are members who are thinking about whether they want to support him or not. He’s not there yet.”
The caucus has gone as far as labeling Johnson an “abysmal failure,” citing concerns about his strategic decision-making and inability to inspire confidence within the GOP’s conservative base.
Johnson’s tenure as Speaker began with challenges, as he was seen as a compromise candidate after Kevin McCarthy’s tumultuous removal. While he managed to secure the position, Johnson has struggled to unify a deeply divided Republican Party, which holds only a razor-thin majority in the House.
With such slim margins, even a small group of dissenting Republicans could derail Johnson’s leadership, mirroring the chaotic process that saw McCarthy take 15 rounds of voting to secure the gavel in 2023.
In an apparent effort to solidify his position, Johnson has worked to align himself with President-elect Donald Trump. He has accompanied Trump to high-profile events, including trips to Mar-a-Lago and a UFC fight.
However, critics within the GOP argue that these appearances, while politically symbolic, fail to address concerns about Johnson’s effectiveness as a leader. “I wouldn’t honestly put too much into that,” a Freedom Caucus member noted, suggesting that party members are more interested in a leader with strategic foresight.
This is not the first time Johnson’s leadership has been called into question. In May 2024, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) introduced a motion to remove Johnson as Speaker, accusing him of betraying Republican principles and failing to fulfill promises made to voters.
“For Americans watching, this is the Uniparty,” Greene declared during her fiery speech, blaming Johnson for what she described as a failure to uphold conservative values.
The motion ultimately failed, with 196 Republicans and 163 Democrats voting to keep Johnson in the role. Greene decried the bipartisan support for Johnson as a betrayal, calling it “disgraceful” and a sign of establishment politics prevailing over grassroots conservatism.
The prospect of another leadership battle raises serious concerns for the GOP, particularly as President-elect Trump prepares to take office. A drawn-out fight over the speakership could stall legislative progress and weaken the party’s ability to implement its agenda.
Critics within the Freedom Caucus argue that Johnson’s leadership could jeopardize key initiatives, including border security, tax reform, and defense spending. They view replacing him as a necessary step to ensure the party remains aligned with Trump’s policy vision.
On the other hand, Johnson’s supporters argue that his leadership reflects the need for unity in a divided Congress. They warn that another leadership fight could damage the party’s credibility and distract from governing.
The push to replace Johnson underscores ongoing divisions within the Republican Party. The rift between establishment Republicans and the populist, Trump-aligned wing continues to shape the party’s internal dynamics.
For the Freedom Caucus, challenging Johnson is about more than leadership—it’s an effort to steer the GOP toward a harder line, emphasizing conservative principles and loyalty to Trump’s vision.
However, this internal strife comes at a time when Republicans face significant challenges, including a narrowly held House majority and a Democratic-controlled Senate. The stakes are high for the party as it seeks to balance its competing factions while advancing its legislative goals.
As January approaches, Johnson faces a critical test of his leadership. He must rally support within the Republican Conference to secure his position and prevent another drawn-out leadership fight.
For the Freedom Caucus, the decision to challenge Johnson represents a broader battle over the party’s future direction. Will the GOP unite behind its current leadership, or will internal divisions continue to disrupt its ability to govern effectively?
The next few weeks will reveal the party’s path forward—and whether Johnson can weather the storm brewing within his ranks. For now, his critics’ message remains clear: step up, or step aside.
The only divisions in the Republican Party is ousting the RHINOS. And over the years we have several. Not tons but a few.