South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem has pledged to eliminate the controversial CBP One mobile application, dubbed by critics as President Joe Biden’s “concierge service” for illegal immigrants, should she take federal office. Her promise comes amid increasing scrutiny of the Biden administration’s handling of border security, which many conservatives argue has been alarmingly lax.
The CBP One app, introduced under the Biden administration, allows migrants to schedule appointments at ports of entry to request asylum. While the administration claims the app streamlines border processes and ensures orderly entry, critics argue that it essentially facilitates illegal immigration by providing an easy pathway for migrants to enter the United States.
Noem, who has gained national attention as a staunch conservative and potential 2024 presidential contender, minced no words about her intentions. Speaking on the issue, she declared, “This app is a blatant invitation for illegal migrants to exploit our system. On my first day in office, I will shut it down.” Her statement reflects growing frustration among conservatives who view the app as emblematic of the Biden administration’s failure to secure the southern border.
Kristi Noem just pledged to shut down the CBP One app.
I can’t believe this app was even created. Democrats are a clear and present danger to America.
— Spitfire (@DogRightGirl) January 17, 2025
CBP One: A Flashpoint in Border Policy
Since its rollout, CBP One has faced significant criticism. The app allows migrants to apply for asylum from their home countries, avoiding the arduous and often dangerous journey to the U.S. border. Proponents argue that it reduces overcrowding at ports of entry and prevents humanitarian crises. However, opponents contend that it encourages migrants to bypass legal immigration channels, overwhelming an already strained immigration system.
Statistics highlight the app’s impact. According to Customs and Border Protection (CBP) data, over 200,000 appointments were scheduled through the app in 2023 alone. Critics assert that these figures represent a de facto increase in illegal immigration, as many applicants lack proper documentation or meet dubious asylum criteria.
Conservatives, including Noem, argue that this approach undermines national sovereignty and disrespects the rule of law. “America cannot be a country without borders,” Noem stated. “This app undermines the hard work of those who follow the legal process and puts our citizens’ safety at risk.”
Biden Administration’s Defense
The Biden administration has defended the CBP One app as a modern solution to an age-old problem. Administration officials have emphasized that the app improves efficiency and reduces chaos at border crossings. By pre-scheduling asylum appointments, they argue, the app minimizes overcrowding and deters illegal crossings between ports of entry.
However, critics argue that these justifications ring hollow in the face of overwhelming numbers. Reports suggest that many migrants misuse the system, filing fraudulent asylum claims to gain entry. Once inside the U.S., enforcement of deportation orders remains inconsistent, exacerbating the strain on resources.
A Broader Debate on Immigration
Noem’s vow to end CBP One reflects a broader debate within American politics about immigration policy. Conservatives have long advocated for stricter border controls, including the completion of the border wall and increased deportations. Noem’s stance aligns with these priorities, positioning her as a champion for those who believe Biden’s policies have compromised national security.
The issue is likely to play a central role in upcoming elections. Republicans see immigration as a winning issue, with polls consistently showing that a majority of Americans favor stronger border enforcement. By taking a hardline stance, Noem aims to galvanize conservative voters and differentiate herself from rivals.
Public Response and Implications
Noem’s pledge has drawn applause from conservatives and border state officials who have borne the brunt of the immigration crisis. Arizona rancher John Smith praised Noem’s commitment, saying, “It’s about time someone took this issue seriously. Our communities are overwhelmed, and this app is making things worse.”
Meanwhile, liberal critics have dismissed Noem’s plan as short-sighted, arguing that eliminating CBP One could lead to more chaos at the border. However, Noem’s supporters counter that order cannot be restored until immigration policies prioritize enforcement over convenience.
A Clear Conservative Vision
By pledging to dismantle CBP One, Kristi Noem underscores her commitment to a conservative vision of immigration reform. Her stance reflects growing dissatisfaction with policies perceived as undermining the rule of law and national security. Whether her promise resonates with voters remains to be seen, but her message is clear: America’s borders must be secure, and the law must be respected.
